Legal Battle Over Short-Term Rentals Highlights Ongoing Tensions in Residential Estates
By Helen Melon Properties · Originally published Friday, December 12, 2025
A significant legal dispute involving short-term letting (STL) — such as Airbnb-style rentals — has put the spotlight once again on how South African residential estates manage, regulate, and enforce community living rules.
The latest case centres around The Blyde Riverwalk Estate in Pretoria, a popular lifestyle development by Balwin Properties, and raises important questions for property owners, investors, and homeowners associations across the country.
How the Dispute Began
During the 2020 Covid-19 lockdowns, The Blyde became a sought-after escape for Gauteng residents looking for a “beach holiday” experience, thanks to its signature crystal-clear lagoon and resort-style amenities. This surge in demand led many owners — particularly investors — to capitalise on short-term holiday rentals.
However, the influx of visitors triggered concerns among full-time residents who reported noise, disruptive behaviour and increased pressure on the estate’s security. In response, the estate’s Homeowners Association (HOA) strengthened its conduct rules in 2020, implementing:
- A minimum three-month letting period unless prior trustee approval was granted;
- A requirement for owners to notify trustees of any short-term occupants;
- A penalty equal to 90% of the monthly levy for owners who violated the rule.
These rules were later approved by the Community Schemes Ombud Service (CSOS) in December 2021.
Owners Challenge the New Rules
A group of 81 owners who rely on short-term letting opposed the amendments, arguing that the new rules were unreasonable. In January 2022, a CSOS adjudicator ruled in their favour, invalidating the October 2021 meeting and instructing the HOA to revert to the original 2018 clause.
This order was then made an official court order in May 2022.
The Matter Goes to Court
Balwin Properties, the HOA, and an individual owner appealed the decision and asked the High Court to suspend the CSOS order pending the outcome of the appeal.
Acting Judge M. Nair recently ruled that:
- There may be grounds for the appeal to succeed, particularly because the CSOS had previously approved the same clause it later rejected.
- The adjudicator’s decision could interfere with the HOA’s authority to follow the Sectional Titles Schemes Management Act (STSMA).
- It would be unfair to impose a full prohibition on STL while the appeal is ongoing.
Key Outcome for Owners and Residents
The court stayed part of the CSOS order, meaning the 2020 conduct rules remain in effect for now — including the restrictions on letting for less than three months without prior approval.
The judge noted the financial impact on STL owners but emphasised the need for balance while the legal process unfolds. The 81 owners who challenged the rules were ordered to pay the legal costs.
What This Means for Property Owners
This case highlights an increasingly common point of friction within community schemes:
- Investors seek flexibility to maximise returns through short-term rentals.
- Residents prioritise stability, security, and quality of life.
- HOAs are under pressure to manage both expectations while ensuring legal compliance.
As short-term letting grows in popularity across South Africa, similar disputes may continue to surface.
If you’re considering purchasing in a lifestyle estate or have questions about STL policies, our team at Helen Melon Properties is here to help guide you through the legal, financial and lifestyle considerations — ensuring your investment aligns with your goals and the community’s rules.
Thinking of buying or selling in Plett?
Talk to the Helen Melon Properties team for honest, local advice.


