High Court Ruling Challenges B-BBEE Requirement for Property Practitioners
By Helen Melon Properties · Originally published Tuesday, September 22, 2026
A significant development for South Africa’s property industry
A recent Pretoria High Court judgement has brought an important change – and some uncertainty – to the regulatory landscape for South African property practitioners.
The court has declared unconstitutional the provision in the Property Practitioners Act that linked the issuing of a Fidelity Fund Certificate (FFC) to possession of a valid B-BBEE certificate.
The case was brought by business organisation Sakeliga following a dispute with the Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority (PPRA) over the requirement.
For estate agencies and other property businesses, this is a significant development. However, there are still some important steps to come before the position is finally settled.
What is an FFC?
A Fidelity Fund Certificate is an essential part of operating legally as a property practitioner in South Africa.
The Property Practitioners Act requires those falling within the definition of a property practitioner to hold an FFC, and operating without one can have serious legal consequences.
The issue at the centre of this case was whether the PPRA could make a B-BBEE certificate a condition for issuing that licence.
How did the dispute start?
In 2024, the PPRA introduced a position that caused considerable concern within the property industry: businesses could be refused an FFC if they did not meet specified B-BBEE requirements.
Sakeliga challenged this approach in court.
The organisation argued that the Property Practitioners Act required an applicant to be in possession of a “valid BEE certificate”, but did not clearly define what constituted a valid certificate, who needed to provide it or what level of B-BBEE compliance was required.
Interestingly, the PPRA subsequently changed its position in 2024 and confirmed that having a “valid” B-BBEE certificate did not necessarily mean achieving a particular B-BBEE level. The PPRA has also stated that, in practice, it has continued issuing FFCs irrespective of the level of B-BBEE compliance.
Sakeliga nevertheless continued with its broader constitutional challenge.
What did the High Court decide?
The Pretoria High Court struck down section 50(a)(x) of the Property Practitioners Act 22 of 2019, which provided the statutory basis for the B-BBEE certificate requirement.
The court found that the provision did not provide sufficient legal certainty.
In simple terms, the legislation did not make it clear enough what “a valid BEE certificate” meant, who was required to have one, or what standard had to be met.
The court therefore found that the provision could not simply be interpreted differently or “fixed” by the court. Any new requirements would be a matter for Parliament to determine.
What does this mean for property practitioners?
This is where things become particularly interesting.
Sakeliga's interpretation of the judgment is that the PPRA may no longer refuse to issue an FFC because an applicant does not hold a B-BBEE certificate.
However, the PPRA has indicated that it interprets the court order differently and believes the relevant declarations are suspended pending confirmation by the Constitutional Court.
Property Professional reports that PPRA CEO Thato Ramaili said the orders would only take effect once the Constitutional Court confirms the declaration.
The Real Estate Business Owners of South Africa (REBOSA), however, has expressed a different interpretation, saying the court order provides interim relief and that the PPRA may not refuse an FFC on the basis of non-compliance with section 50(a)(x) while the matter awaits the Constitutional Court.
So, while the High Court judgment is significant, the practical position is still developing.
It is not only about B-BBEE
The case also challenged the broad definition of a “property practitioner” contained in the Property Practitioners Act.
The High Court found parts of that definition to be unconstitutional and narrowed the categories of people who fall within the definition.
Among the examples highlighted are certain private property owners, some advertisers, and people dealing with specified property interests outside the ordinary course of business.
The judgment also has implications for property portals.
According to Property Professional's report on the judgment, a person whose role is limited to hosting or publishing advertisements placed by someone else, without otherwise participating in the sale, marketing or promotion of the property, falls outside the definition of a property practitioner.
What happens next?
Because the judgment concerns the constitutionality of legislation passed by Parliament, the matter must go to the Constitutional Court for confirmation.
If the declaration is confirmed, Parliament will have a period of 24 months to address the parts of the legislation relating to the definition of property practitioner.
This means the story is not quite over.
The High Court ruling represents a significant legal development, but property practitioners should continue to monitor official PPRA guidance while the Constitutional Court process takes place.
What should property practitioners do now?
For now, the sensible approach is to remain compliant with the requirements that are clearly in force and to keep an eye on official PPRA communications.
The PPRA's current FFC renewal information still refers to a valid B-BBEE certificate where applicable, while its online business-property-practitioner application requirements also continue to list a B-BBEE certificate among the documents required.
In other words, this judgment should not be interpreted as meaning that all PPRA compliance requirements have suddenly disappeared.
The FFC remains an important requirement for property practitioners, and other regulatory obligations under the Property Practitioners Act remain in place.
A significant moment for the property industry
The judgment raises broader questions about how transformation policy and economic regulation should interact with the right to conduct business.
For the property industry, the immediate significance is much more straightforward: a provision that linked a property's practitioner’s ability to obtain an FFC with B-BBEE certification has been declared unconstitutional by the High Court.
The final position will depend on the Constitutional Court process and any subsequent changes Parliament may make to the legislation.
At Helen Melon Properties, we will continue to follow developments and keep our clients and colleagues informed as the regulatory position becomes clearer.
This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Property practitioners should obtain independent professional advice regarding their individual circumstances and regulatory obligations.
Thinking of buying or selling in Plett?
Talk to the Helen Melon Properties team for honest, local advice.


